The Law Office of Michael T. Heider, P.A. A Wills, Trusts, Estate And Elder Issues Practice

Quality Florida Probate Services are our priority.

Contested and Uncontested Probate: Understanding the Differences


In Florida, probate is the legal process of administering the estate of a deceased person. Depending on the circumstances and the level of disagreement among interested parties, probate can be either contested or uncontested.

What is Uncontested Probate?

Uncontested probate occurs when all parties involved, including beneficiaries and interested parties, agree on the distribution of assets and the validity of the will. In such cases, the process tends to be more straightforward and typically involves the court confirming the will, appointing the executor, and overseeing the distribution of assets as per the terms outlined in the will.

What is a Contested Probate?

Contested probate arises when there is a disagreement or dispute regarding the distribution of assets, the validity of the will, or the appointment of the executor. It can be a complex and contentious process that requires legal intervention to resolve the issues. Common reasons for contested probate include allegations of undue influence, lack of capacity of the deceased, or improper execution of the will.

Contested vs Uncontested Probate in Florida

1) Contested Probate:

  • Disputes: In contested probate, there are disagreements or disputes among the interested parties regarding the validity of the will, the distribution of assets, or the appointment of the personal representative (executor).
  • Court Involvement: Contested probate cases often require court involvement and may proceed to estate litigation. The court will make decisions on the disputed matters based on evidence, testimonies, and applicable laws.
  • Legal Representation: It is common for parties involved in contested probate to hire attorneys to represent their interests and advocate for their positions during the legal proceedings.
  • Lengthy Process: Due to the complexity of resolving disputes and the involvement of the court, contested probate cases can be protracted and may take a considerable amount of time to reach a resolution.
  • Higher Costs: Contested probate cases generally involve more legal work, court fees, and expenses related to gathering evidence and legal opinions, making them more expensive compared to uncontested probate.

2) Uncontested Probate:

  • Agreement and Cooperation: Uncontested probate occurs when all interested parties, including beneficiaries and heirs, are in agreement regarding the distribution of assets, appointment of the personal representative, and other matters related to the estate administration.
  • Limited Court Involvement: In uncontested probate cases, court involvement is minimal. The personal representative typically submits the necessary documents and forms to the court, and if everything is in order, the court approves the administration of the estate without the need for extensive hearings or litigation.
  • Simplified Process: Uncontested probate cases tend to be simpler and more streamlined, as there are no major disputes or conflicts to resolve. This usually results in a faster and more cost-effective probate process.
  • Less Legal Representation: In uncontested probate, parties involved may not require extensive legal representation unless they prefer to have legal guidance throughout the process.

It’s important to note that even in uncontested probate, it is advisable for the personal representative to consult an attorney to ensure compliance with Florida probate laws and to facilitate the efficient administration of the estate. Additionally, probate laws and procedures can vary, so it’s always recommended to seek professional legal advice specific to your situation in Florida.

In summary, uncontested probate proceeds smoothly when all parties agree on the distribution of assets and the validity of the will. On the other hand, contested probate arises when there are disputes, such as allegations of undue influence, lack of capacity of the deceased, or improper execution of the will. In contested cases, legal representation becomes crucial in navigating the probate process and advocating for one’s interests.

Contact Michael T. Heider, P.A. today to hire an experienced probate attorney in Florida.